Dragonslayers may share ancient Roman roots
By Charles Choi
UPI Science News

ATLANTA, Sept. 10 (UPI) -- Dragonslaying legends from fairy tales, classic operas and modern fantasy may find roots in an ancient cult of Roman soldiers, according to a recent study from the University of Georgia in Atlanta.

"Stories about fighting monsters go back further than anyone knows, but particular details of these stories can definitely be traced back to this mystery religion," said lead researcher Don Beistle, now at the Georgia Institute of Technology in Atlanta.

The study focused on the father of all fairy tale princes, the dragonslayer Siegfried, who is immortalized in Wagner's classic opera "The Nibelungenlied." In ancient Germanic folklore, Siegfried fought a dragon with a magic sword and a cloak of invisibility to win a cave full of treasure and the hand of the sleeping beauty Brynhilde -- a tale that has influenced countless other stories, including J.R.R. Tolkien's modern fantasy epic, "The Lord of the Rings."

Scholars have long suspected an even earlier source for the Siegfried legend -- the classic Greek myth of Perseus, who donned a helmet of invisibility to kill the monstrous Medusa and then later rescued the princess Andromeda from a sea dragon. But until now, no one was sure how the two heroes might have become linked across the millennia.

Researcher Don Beistle believes he has found that bridge -- the mysterious Roman cult of Mithras, which Beistle thinks brought dragonslaying imagery into the Rhineland.

"Mithraism can explain how this story leaps from classical Mediterranean civilizations to Europe," Beistle said in an interview with United Press International. "The whole layout of the popular dragon fight that you see in everything from the operas of Wagner to Tolkien, even stuff you see in video games -- the magic heirloom sword, the beast in his underground lair -- all that goes back unwittingly to this mythic paradigm from the Mithraists."

Mithraism was a cult popular among Roman soldiers, whose rites were secret to outsiders. The cult worshipped the youthful deity Mithras -- who recent studies suggest is derived from Perseus -- with ceremonies that celebrated their god's slaughter of a cosmic bull.

In his study, Beistle theorizes that Roman troops stationed on the northern fringes of the empire brought Mithraism to local German tribes along the Rhine. Over time, elements of the Perseus tale were absorbed into the local identity of Siegfried.

"The monster-slaying story would have been a coming-of-age tale for the Germans," Beistle told UPI. "The reflection of a ritual whereby a youth became a young man -- alone and naked, armed only with their bare hands or a single blade, he faced the most terrifying thing in the universe, this ultimate chaos, the ultimate threat, and he overcame it."

The evidence for this connection? The cult's gem-studded cave temple walls, which mimicked the starry heavens. These temples were always near fresh springs and illuminated by sacred fires that flanked the altar.

"All of these things -- cave, flowing water, fire and shimmering light glinting off gold and jewels -- also appear in medieval Germanic descriptions of the dragon's lair in the Siegfried story," Beistle said.

Jonathan Evans, director of medieval studies at the University of Georgia, feels that Beistle makes a fairly strong argument.

"The parallels really are there," Evans told UPI. "My cautionary remarks would be that this is very ancient material, and one of the pitfalls of folklore is over interpretation. Don saves himself from that charge from careful and exhaustive research."

"This research and others like it demonstrates that even some of our most popular legends and icons are of extreme antiquity," he added. "The world didn't spring into existence a half-hour ago, and these ancient myths still speak to us in very deep ways."

Beistle recently presented his study at the International Medieval Studies Congress in Kalamazoo, Mich.

Return to main menu.